Time for a riddle of sorts.
Image via Wikipedia
It’s a very unique type of riddle. Here it is:
5 of history’s greatest physicists are sitting at a round table. They’re faced with a problem.
Physicist Number One proposes a plausible solution. The others then pose potential solutions.
They then discuss problems with the various solutions. All of the solutions are great ideas. Many of the ideas contradict each other.
Physicist Number One never repeats his solution or argues for it. No one ever repeats anyone’s idea.
After some debate, the Chairman says, “Well, it’s time to make a decision. Number One’s solution is clearly the best.”
They all instantly agree that Number One’s solution is the best.
Question: Why is there no arguing?
There are multiple answers to this. It isn’t a logic puzzle. This is a puzzle concerning intellectual fields and human social dynamics.
This scenario actually was one encountered by the incredibly interesting character Richard Feynman. Feynman concludes, or perhaps assumes, 1 reason why this happens.
I can think of 5 very distinct forces that could each cause this to happen (that aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive).
What is your answer? (Or set of answers).
Think of as many distinct forces as you can that caused them to reach a decision without arguing, and write your answer in the comments or send me an email. I’ll post my answer (and Feynman’s) in the comments on Sunday evening.
-Kevin
10.21.2011
p.s. Here’s the first letter of each of my answers to help remind me what I thought of. Feel free to try to use them to your advantage.
p
a
g
c
d
